Skip to content
Dilly Labs

What's the Dilly-o with staff identity & access: a buyer's guide for credit unions

On Dec. 15, 2025, Educational Employees Credit Union learned that someone had gotten into one employee email account.1 On May 8, 2026, a review confirmed that personal information may have been accessed.2

The Dilly-o

Attackers phone the help desk posing as staff to reset passwords and move multi-factor authentication (MFA).3 Most credit unions should start with the basics: know who has access to what, and cut access the day someone leaves.

How we'd size up a vendor

  1. Joiners and leavers - when human resources (HR) marks a termination, how fast does access disappear from your core, digital banking admin and email? Ask whether the tool removes access itself or only creates a task for someone to do it.
  2. Access reviews - can the tool show who has access to what across every system and produce a report your examiner will accept? Ask to see a sample review that a department manager would sign off on.
  3. Privileged access - how does the vendor handle admin accounts, default passwords and re-checking identity before a configuration change? Your admins should use separate accounts for admin work, and the tool should make that easy.
  4. Reset defense - how does the tool confirm a caller is really your employee before resetting a password or moving MFA? Ask the vendor to walk you through a reset request that fails the check, step by step.

What changed this year

On Sept. 16, 2025, the National Credit Union Administration (NCUA) released an updated ACET cybersecurity assessment tool mapped to NIST CSF 2.0.4 In one report, 96 percent reported more targeted social engineering over the past 12 months.5 Help desk resets are now a named attack path, with actors posing as employees to move MFA to devices they control.3

Will it work with your systems?

Your core and digital banking platform already carry some staff access controls. Jack Henry Identity supports SMS, phone call, authenticator apps and FIDO security keys as second factors.6 The April 2017 Q2central administration guide assigns each customer service representative (CSR) user exactly one CSR role, from level 1 through level 5.7 On Symitar, user provisioning is manual or runs through custom integrations with the SymXchange API.8 We haven't yet reviewed Provision IAM's fit with any core.C Ask any provider to show a live connection to your core and digital banking platform, and whether it removes access there or only flags it.

What other credit unions did

Platinum Federal Credit Union spotted suspicious activity in an employee email account on March 27, 2025.9 At Co-op Credit Union, an unauthorized actor used an internal employee account from April 8 to April 18, 2025.10 Patelco's ransomware attack caused more than $39 million in losses, per its 2024 financial filing.11 It also agreed to a consent order with state regulators, paying a $100,000 penalty and putting in a new cybersecurity program.12

What your examiner will ask

The FFIEC handbook asks for timely notice from HR to security administrators of job changes, including terminations.13 We'd keep your access approval records, your latest access review and your termination log in one place, ready to show.

What it costs

Published prices for staff identity tools are quoted per user per month.1415 One pricing roundup puts IBM Security Verify at about $1.80, Cisco Duo at $3 to $9 and OneLogin at $4 to $6.14 Per one third-party guide, Okta's three published suites run $6, $14 or $17 per user per month, billed annually.15 Whichever vendor you shortlist, we'd ask for a written quote that covers every system you need connected. The NCUA notes that early termination and escape terms are often negotiable, and contracts should allow ending for your own convenience.1617

Food for thought

Attackers now push urgent MFA or passkey updates and send staff to lookalike sign-in pages.18 We'd treat any change to how staff sign in as a moment that needs its own checks. Before you roll out passkeys or a new tool, we'd decide how staff will know a real reset request from a fake one.

Dilly Labs research, written from our catalog and cited sources · updated . Credit unions pay nothing. Vendors pay a referral fee only when a contract is signed through us. It never changes rankings or this guide. How we work

Sources

  1. Educational Employees Credit Union Data Breach Exposes SSNswww.claimdepot.com
    On Dec. 15, 2025, Educational Employees Credit Union learned that an unauthorized individual gained access to one employee email account for a limited...
  2. Educational Employees Credit Union Data Breach Exposes SSNswww.claimdepot.com
    On May 8, 2026, nearly five months after the initial incident, the review confirmed that the unauthorized actor may have accessed or acquired personal...
  3. Stopping help desk social engineering on password and MFAsafeguard.sh
    Since July 2025 the advisory also describes actors posing as employees to get help desk staff to reset passwords and move MFA to devices the attackers...
  4. FFIEC CAT Sunset: What Banks and Credit Unions Should Use Instead in 2026 — and What Examiners Now Expectrisktemplate.com
    On September 16, 2025, the NCUA released an updated ACET application that: retained all original FFIEC CAT content for continuity; mapped the tool to ...
  5. Social engineering attacks are rising as employee data becomes easier to exploitwww.biometricupdate.com
    According to the survey, 96 percent of cybersecurity leaders reported an increase in targeted social engineering attempts over the past 12 months.
  6. Jack Henry Identityjackhenry.dev
    Supported 2FA methods include SMS, phone call, authenticator apps, and FIDO security keys.
  7. Q2central Administration Guide 4.3 Release April 2017centralinstall.onlineaccess1.com
    Each CSR User is assigned to exactly one CSR Role. CSR Roles range from level 1 (L1) through level 5 (L5).
  8. Symitar SCIM Provisioning: Pricing & Limitationswww.stitchflow.com
    User provisioning must be managed manually or through custom API integrations via the SymXchange API, which requires significant technical development...
  9. PFCU Data Breach Affects SSNs and Financial Infowww.claimdepot.com
    On March 27, 2025, the financial institution detected suspicious activity within an employee email account.
  10. Co-op Credit Union Data Breach Affects 8 in MAwww.claimdepot.com
    The credit union discovered that an unauthorized actor gained access to an internal employee account between April 8, 2025 and April 18, 2025.
  11. June Deadline Set in $7.2 Million Patelco Ransomware Breach Settlementwww.cutimes.com
    The ransomware attack caused more than $39 million in losses, according to Patelco's 2024 financial filing.
  12. June Deadline Set in $7.2 Million Patelco Ransomware Breach Settlementwww.cutimes.com
    In February 2025, the credit union agreed to a consent order with state regulators to pay a $100,000 penalty and implement a new cybersecurity program...
  13. FFIEC IT Examination Handbook InfoBase - II.C.7(b) User Access Programithandbook.ffiec.gov
    - Timely notification from human resources to security administrators to adjust user access based on job changes, including terminations.
  14. Identity Service Pricing 2026: Okta, Entra ID & Hideezhideez.com
    Workforce SSO + MFA typically runs $1.80–$9 per user/month: IBM Security Verify ~$1.80, Cisco Duo $3–$9, Microsoft Entra ID P1 $6 / P2 $9, Okta $6–$17...
  15. Okta Pricing 2026: Plans From $6 per User and Hidden Costsunderdefense.com
    Okta Workforce Identity costs $6, $14, or $17 per user per month for the three suites with a published price, and Okta’s own pricing FAQ confirms that...
  16. ​Evaluating Third Party Relationshipsncua.gov
    For example, some credit unions have entered into third party agreements with significant buyout or termination penalties, believing the penalties or ...
  17. Relationships with Third Parties that Provide Services Related to Digital Assetsncua.gov
    Contracts should contain a provision that permits the FICU to terminate the contract for both cause and for the convenience of the FICU.
  18. Help Desk Social Engineering: How to Stop Itwww.cyberqp.ai
    The caller pushes an urgent MFA or passkey update and sends the employee to a lookalike sign-in page that captures their credentials and MFA tokens.
See the 2 staff identity & access vendorsSorted by fit with your core, with the evidence behind each.